Zaxecivobuny (zaxec) wrote,
Zaxecivobuny
zaxec

A new religion?

I have just changed my facebook info page's Religious Views to "Prisoner's Dilemmist."

This is a reference to the classic problem, the Prisoner's Dilemma (I shrink at the thought that I am insulting my reader's intelligence here).

I have decided that my morality from now until I change my mind(I don't expect to do so) will be based on adherence to the cooperative portion of the prisoner's dilemma. It's sorta like a game theorist's answer to the golden rule. Let me explain.

Let's face it: The payoff from stealing things is high, and the chance of getting caught is low. As an economics student I can't ignore the expected value of occasional thievery as positive for the thief.

However, if I steal from anyone, I am made marginally better off, but they are likely made proportionately worse off. Moreover, if everyone steals from everyone, we will all spend all our time worrying about protecting our things and not have time to live our lives. This is unacceptable.

If I decide not to steal from anyone, they may still steal from me, but there is also the possibility of punishment for them, and more importantly, I wish to demonstrate my intention to enter into a stable equilibrium of "no one steals" and I can broadcast this by sticking to my principles in spite of being a victim of theft.

Let me say that I was not a thief before I wrote this, this is merely a way for me to logically justify continuing my (arguably economically irrational) behavior.

Let me also say that I refuse to appeal to a higher authority who refuses to show up for court (or indeed, at all) to justify moral behavior. I'm still an atheist. This system allows for atheist morality.
Subscribe

  • The Story of the Shark Ghost

    So, my friend and co-worker Chrissy is afraid of ghosts. And sharks. This weekend I mentioned this to Robert and he got a great idea and called her,…

  • take home test from my first semester at UMSL

    I came across this today, and I really like it, so here it is: [questions 1 and 2 were in-class, 3 and 4 were take home. I'm pretty sure the…

  • Year End Update

    I wish I had accomplished more this year. Here's what I did. In the last couple days I received this in the mail. I am typing this entry on it. I…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic
    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 14 comments

  • The Story of the Shark Ghost

    So, my friend and co-worker Chrissy is afraid of ghosts. And sharks. This weekend I mentioned this to Robert and he got a great idea and called her,…

  • take home test from my first semester at UMSL

    I came across this today, and I really like it, so here it is: [questions 1 and 2 were in-class, 3 and 4 were take home. I'm pretty sure the…

  • Year End Update

    I wish I had accomplished more this year. Here's what I did. In the last couple days I received this in the mail. I am typing this entry on it. I…